SME Times is powered by   
Search News
Just in:   • Healthy Monsoon forecast, global cues pushes equities higher  • ECLGS 2.0 now covers SMA-1 borrowers  • Forex reserves up by over $4 bn  • Honda Cars India to recall 77,954 units  • Industrial activity to continue despite surge: Haryana CM 
Last updated: 27 Sep, 2014  

fdi-indiaTHMB.jpg 'Consumer is king' says SC; rejects plea against retail FDI

Supreme.Court.9.jpg
   Top Stories
» ECLGS 2.0 now covers SMA-1 borrowers
» Forex reserves up by over $4 bn
» Industry seeks reimposition of bankruptcy moratorium
» 'Govt should regulate cryptocurrencies, not ban them'
» Startups new champions of Aatmanirbhar Bharat: Goyal
SME Times News Bureau | 02 May, 2013
"Consumer is the king", the Supreme Court said Wednesday upholding the government's policy of allowing foreign direct investment (FDI) in multi-brand retail, holding that it did not suffer from any constitutional infirmity.

While the court underlined the consumer's supremacy, it described the middleman as an "enemy", "sucker", "curse" and "Shylock" of the retail market.

The apex court bench of Justice R.M. Lodha, Justice Madan B. Lokur and Justice Kurien Joseph said: "On matters affecting policy, this court does not interfere unless the policy is unconstitutional, contrary to statutory provisions, arbitrary, irrational, or in abuse of power."

"Consumer is the king. Middleman is the enemy of the retail market. Middleman is a sucker of the economy and if he is being eliminated then it directly benefits the consumer and the producer," Justice Lodha said.

Dismissing a petition challenging FDI in multi-brand retail, the court said the impugned policy did not suffer from any vires and there was no merit in the challenge.

The policy was challenged by advocate M.L. Sharma who contended that FDI in multi-brand retail was introduced by issuing two press notes, without amending the provisions and rules regulating the sector.

Noting that permitting FDI in multi-brand retail was aimed at eliminating the middleman from the retail market and to benefit the consumer and the producer, Justice Lodha said: "Middlemen are a curse to the economy and they work like Shylock."

As Sharma insisted that FDI in multi-brand retail would eliminate the traditional retail marketing chain in the country, Justice Lodha gave the example of the onion producers in Maharashtra's Nashik.

Justice Lodha said while the onion growers of Nashik didn't get even Re.1 per kg for their produce, the same was sold for Rs.25 per kg to the consumer.

Referring to the government's reply to the petition, the court said the experience of China, Brazil, Indonesia, Thailand and other countries showed that both the organised and unorganised sector in retail market could co-exist and grow.

"Why don't you expect that happening in India?" asked the court.

The government in its affidavit said the prime focus in allowing the FDI in multi-brand retail was to "benefit the consumer by enlarging the choice of purchase".

The government pointed to a World Bank report which said the average price that farmer received for a typical horticulture product was only 12-15 percent of the price the consumer paid at a retail outlet.

The court also pointed to the Indian Council for Research and International Economic Relations report which said "unorganised and organised retail not only co-exist, but also grow substantially in size, as a result of the growth of organised retail".
 
Print the Page Add to Favorite
 
Share this on :
 

Please comment on this story:
 
Subject :
Message:
(Maximum 1500 characters)  Characters left 1500
Your name:
 

 
  Customs Exchange Rates
Currency Import Export
US Dollar
66.20
64.50
UK Pound
87.50
84.65
Euro
78.25
75.65
Japanese Yen 58.85 56.85
As on 17 Apr, 2021
  Daily Poll
COVID-19 has directly affected your business
 Yes
 No
 Can't say
  Commented Stories
» Covid second wave: Lockdown or no lockdown(2)
 
 
About Us  |   Advertise with Us  
  Useful Links  |   Terms and Conditions  |   Disclaimer  |   Contact Us  
Follow Us : Facebook Twitter